New Gideon’s Bakehouse Location Coming to Disney Springs, Permits and Artwork Tell the Story

Few treats at Walt Disney World generate the fervour of Gideon’s Bakehouse cookies. The original Disney Springs location routinely sees lines stretching down the block for its half‑pound cookies and towering cakes. Now, dessert lovers have something new to buzz about: a second Gideon’s Bakehouse location appears to be on the way. WDW News Today spotted artwork and confirmed permits that suggest the cult‑favorite bakery is expanding within Disney Springs.

The Evidence

Earlier this month, theme park reporters noticed Gothic‑style artwork plastered on the windows of a long‑vacant storefront at 1600 E. Buena Vista Dr., Suite C‑22 — the former home of The Art of Shaving. The red‑and‑black art features birds, crowns and swords reminiscent of Gideon’s branding. The windows also display a sign reading “Please Pardon Our Appearance | Something New is Coming Soon,” a classic Disney precursor to new retail.

But the real smoking gun is a permit filed with the Orange County comptroller. The permit lists a “New Tenant Build‑Out of Lease Space in Disney Springs” at the same address, with Walt Disney World as owner and The First Raven LLC, the company owned by Gideon’s founder Steve Lewis, as client. While the permit doesn’t explicitly name Gideon’s, the pairing of these entities strongly indicates that Gideon’s is behind the project.

Why Another Location?

Gideon’s Bakehouse has built a devoted following since opening its first Disney Springs shop in January 2021. Its limited‑release cookies, like Peanut Butter Crunch and Coffee Cake, often sell out before midday, and lines can reach three hours during peak holidays. A second location could alleviate wait times and give the bakery more space to experiment with flavors and merchandise.

The new spot is not adjacent to the existing store; several businesses separate the two spaces. This suggests it won’t be a simple expansion but rather a distinct venue. Some fans speculate it might focus on cakes or other confections that are currently constrained by the original bakery’s footprint. The Gothic artwork features a crown and sword instead of the usual Gideon’s gargoyle, hinting at a possible spin‑off concept.

The Permit Process

Filing a permit with the county is just the first step. The permit referenced by WDW News Today covers interior build‑out, meaning the space will be renovated to meet the tenant’s needs. Before work begins, the project must pass local inspections for electrical, plumbing and accessibility. Given Disney’s track record, the build should proceed quickly once approved. The permit is dated December 2025 and was last updated on January 3, 2026, which indicates that planning is underway.

It’s worth noting that The First Raven LLC previously filed a permit for the original Disney Springs location, so there’s a precedent. Working with Disney as landlord means the new bakery must adhere to Disney Springs’ design guidelines, ensuring the storefront blends with the district’s eclectic architecture.

What This Means for Visitors

For guests, another Gideon’s location could dramatically reduce wait times. Currently, the queue at the existing shop is managed via a virtual queue during busy periods. A second location would double capacity and could offer indoor seating or a dedicated merchandise shop. If the concept differs, perhaps focusing on cakes or limited‑edition items, it could also encourage repeat visits.

Dessert lovers should keep an eye on the windows for additional clues. Disney often reveals the name and theme of new shops via exterior signage as construction progresses. Follow Gideon’s and Disney Springs on social media for official announcements; until then, treat this as an exciting development rather than a guaranteed opening date.

Gideon’s Origins

Gideon’s Bakehouse began as a tiny stall in Orlando’s East End Market in 2016. Founder Steve Lewis spent years perfecting his cookie recipes, and the bakery quickly gained a cult following. When the Disney Springs location opened, it propelled Gideon’s into the national spotlight. The brand’s dark, Victorian aesthetic and over‑the‑top desserts set it apart in a sea of bright Disney treats. Each cookie is handcrafted, takes over 24 hours to make and weighs nearly half a pound.

Final Thoughts

While Disney has yet to officially confirm a second Gideon’s Bakehouse, the combination of artwork and permits makes it all but certain. Dessert fans should look forward to shorter lines and possibly new menu items. The timing couldn’t be better: with major Disney Springs projects like the Lime Garage refurbishment underway, a sweet new shop offers something to anticipate.

Behind the Wish will monitor the build‑out process and share updates when Disney or Gideon’s makes an official announcement. Until then, keep your eyes peeled during your next Disney Springs visit, you might spot a second gargoyle soon!